In detail
1. The circulating numbers keep failing basic checks
Andy Masley, who taught physics for seven years, fact-checks AI environmental claims, and the largest error he has found personally is a water figure in the book Empire of AI that is off by a factor of about 4,500 (episode 45 at 7:15). One of the two errors behind it: the author’s source had mixed up liters and cubic meters, and a cubic meter is a thousand liters. The published figure implied that each resident of an 88,000-person community outside Santiago was using about a tenth of a liter of water a day, for everything (7:46). That is a number anyone could have sanity-checked, and for six months nobody did. Same chapter, second problem: the claim that AI would consume half as much water as all of Britain by 2027, where the study being cited puts the figure at roughly 5%.
2. One prompt is a rounding error in your day
Masley’s comparisons, for the conversation you actually have at a party: a single prompt probably emits about what printing a fifth of a page of a book does, or running a space heater for half a second, or driving four feet (39:25). On water, his estimate is roughly one eight-hundred-thousandth of your daily use. Anything you do on a computer carries a small climate cost relative to almost everything else in a day, which is why “I ran a thousand searches today” was never a confession.
3. Overstating the number carries its own environmental cost
Masley’s hedged read of what followed the Santiago coverage: activist pressure, possibly built on the bad figure, appears to have pushed Google toward air cooling instead of water cooling (9:30) for that proposed data center, which has not been built. Air cooling takes considerably more energy, so he suspects the redesign would mean higher emissions in exchange for saving water. His corrected estimate puts the facility at about 25% of the water in one section of Santiago, but about 3% of the municipal supply (9:49). As of September 2026, Google says it has not decided whether to go ahead with the redesigned, air-cooled project. Environmental policy is a series of trade-offs, and you cannot price a trade-off with a number that is wrong by three orders of magnitude.
4. The constraint that binds is the grid
Cisco’s Jeetu Patel names infrastructure as the first hard constraint on AI in episode 44 at 11:39: not enough power, compute, network bandwidth, or data-center capacity to meet demand. His framing is that infrastructure is the input and intelligence is the output, and the goal is generating tokens at the lowest kilowatt and the lowest dollar (15:24). That problem is expensive, contested, and unresolved. It is also a different problem from whether you should feel bad for sending a prompt.
Compare measured work, not a universal prompt number
A short text answer, a long agent run and a generated video are different workloads. One measured case is Google’s August 2025 study, which reports 0.24 Wh for the median Gemini Apps text prompt. That figure covers Google’s own serving infrastructure for that product and period, not every model, workload or provider.
Worked example, with numbers invented for teaching: two workflows each deliver 1,000 successful tasks at the same quality. For this exercise both use an illustrative emissions factor of 0.4 kg CO₂e per kWh.
| Metric for 1,000 successful tasks | Workflow A | Workflow B | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Facility electricity | 20 kWh | 12 kWh | 40% less |
| Electricity-associated emissions | 8 kg CO₂e | 4.8 kg CO₂e | 40% less |
| On-site water consumed | 30 L | 45 L | 50% more |
Workflow B uses less electricity per success (12 Wh against 20 Wh) but more on-site water, which is a separate input, not derived from the energy figures. The table doesn’t settle which has the smaller total footprint: indirect water, training and other lifecycle impacts are outside it. For a real comparison, measure the same workload and period, count failed attempts in the resources used, and divide by successful tasks.
Why it matters
Individual guilt and grid policy are two different conversations, and running them together costs you both. Bad numbers lose more than an argument. On Masley’s read, one of them may have pushed the cooling design of a proposed data center the wrong way, which is what it costs to reason from a figure nobody checked.
Disclosure: Episode 45 was sponsored by Galileo, the Season 3 presenting sponsor (thanks at 0:00). Episode 44 was sponsored by Galileo while Conor worked there.
Hear it from the guest
“The number that she gave for this community basically implied that the average person there was consuming about point one liters a day, which is something like a fifth of a single bottle of water”
“Sending a prompt probably emits as much as printing a fifth of a single page of a book, or it's like running a space heater for about half a second, or driving your car for about four feet or something like that.”
Quotes lightly edited to remove filler words.
From the conversation
This explainer is drawn from these episodes — each carries its full transcript.